Which do you like best?

[Big_al]

Better composition?

I can't decide which one of these pictures has the better photographic composition.

The left version
http://img79.imageshack.us/img79/9923/lefthighanddry9oc.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Or the right version?
http://img111.imageshack.us/img111/6095/righthighanddry6ny.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

What do you think and can you tell which one is the original and which is the mirrored?

[FATAL]

The boats on the left look a bit more natural. I suppose that it's the original picture, although the text is hard to see.

[Danimetal]

Heh, he also mirrored the text... So, well, I also think that the boats in the left look more natural. That´s why I like the other best... If you don´t put them together maybe the second one doens´t look unbalanced, but well, that´s it.

I would also say that the second (boats on the right) is the original.

[Hans]

i think the boats on the right are the original because
the text on the boat on the left is a bit out of place

[Big_al]

Thanks for your comments, I was just going to clone out the boat's name but in the end editted it to be the right way round in the mirrored version :)

If you want to see lager versions of the pictures browse to,
http://www.deviantart.com/view/30722400/ and http://www.deviantart.com/view/30722437/

[ace]

Mmyess, left definitely seems better to me.

[Big_al]

Thanks for all you comments.

Actually the picture with the boats on the right hand side is the original version.

I flipped the image and corrected the text in PS to make the "boats of the left" version.

[Muscle Chris]

LOL cheating with the boat text

i like boat on left better, i think it feels more natural since people look left to right so its like the view opens up