Best/Worst Source Port

[Agent Spork]

Only post your opinion.

Top 3:
1.Doom legacy
2.ZDoom
3.JDoom

[X-DOOM]

1- ZDoom
2- ZXDoom (not available)
3- DoomLegacy (the 2nd port i like)
4- EDGE
5- JDOOM
6- VanillaDoom

------------------
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/x-doom/imgs/pub/zd3kpub4.gif
Creator of -=ZD3K=-
The game is now dedicated in memory of my dog Lily (http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/x-doom/indxen.php?p=lily&lang=en)
Born at april 12 1992 and died at october 3 2002. I will never forgot you.
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/x-doom
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/x-doom/imgs/smillies/UTFlagSmilles.gif I will teach you some move during the Deathmatch. - Are you the choosen one?

***

Yes, the more you post here the less time you'll have for doing other computer related crapola . --- Doom_Dude

[Mr. Chris]

1. JDoom
2. ZDoom
3. Doom Legacy

Worst - DOSDoom

[Doom_Dude]

DooM Legacy
JDooM
ZDooM

It's hard to chose between Legacy and Jdoom..... I think they're both cool.

------------------
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad/sig/vilesig1.GIF (http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad/ndcp)
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad/Ndcp/themegawad.JPG (http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad)
----Linedef Technician and Sector Maker Upper----

[Exl]

1 - Doom Legacy
2 - JDoom
3 - ZDoom

89 - Doom Alpha 0.4

------------------
http://home.wanadoo.nl/dennis.meuwissen/temp/sig_link.gif (http://home.wanadoo.nl/dennis.meuwissen/whacked)

One nut can ask more questions than ten wise men can answer.

[Nickster]

1. jDOom
2. Edge
3. Legacy

[DarkWolf]

Legacy, ZDoom, JDoom, Edge

------------------
-DarkWolf
http://www.boomspeed.com/darkwolf/windeuchick.gif

[Ace]

1. Doom Legacy
2. JDoom
3. ZDoom

------------------
....summoned the ghosts of the suitors, and in his hand he held the fair golden wand with which he seals men's eyes in sleep or wakes them just as he pleases; with this he roused the ghosts and led them, while they followed whining and gibbering behind him.

[Rellik_jmd]

There are other sourceports?! I thought there was just Legacy.....

http://forums.newdoom.com/UBB/tongue.gif

------------------
Member of Team DEIM (http://www.teamdeim.com/)
Webmaster The DOOM Editing Resource (http://www.teamdeim.com/der/)

Team Deim.com is TEMPORARILY down. It will be back, maybe in a week or two, but it will be back! DOOM Editing Resource temporary site. (http://www.telusplanet.net/public/daewoo/der/)

[Tim]

There are other sourceports?! I thought there was just Legacy.....

omg, I thought there was only zdoom http://forums.newdoom.com/UBB/frown.gif

[God-l-Send-l-Death]

The only ones I've tried, Edge and ZDoom..... http://forums.newdoom.com/UBB/smilies/cwm1.gif

------------------
I stalk, close in from above
Silent wings will test your faith
Death will never hear me pass
Pray for sin a shattered faith
Down on your knees, you're screaming out to die...

[Kaiser]

Prboom
Eternity
Jdoom
Zdoom
Vanilla Doom
Doom legacy

[picklehammer]

1 ZDOOM, ZDAEMON
2 jdoom
3 Legacy
4 SMMU
5 prboom, boom
6 edge
7 doom.exe/doom2.exe
8 zdoomgl
9 doom 95

------------------

MSN: pickle_hammer@hotmail.com
ICQ: 74527913
Y!: picklehammer
AIM: picklehammmer27
IRC: ph` (irc.freenode.net #zdoom, #zdaemon, #doom3)

[Deathgiver]

IMHO

Best: jDoom

Worst: Doom 95

[XDelusion]

Best to worst list:


1. Legacy

2. ZDOOM

3. JDOOM

4. Vavoom (if only Strife really worked).

------------------
Satan's Girl Scouts

http://files.frashii.com/~sp00nz/Doom/

http://www.angelfire.com/dc/xdelusion/

He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.

[Aliotroph?]

Legacy
JDoom
ZDoom (if it ran on my box it would be beter than JDoom)
ZDoomGL
BooM
Vavoom
Doom95
Doom3D (this version has this funny 3D thing, "the matrix" you can put on your screen to see real 3D using polarized filters but you have to build that)


I have no idea where to put Edge in there because I've never played it.

------------------
"Once in a while a programmer really writes something he's proud of, a slick, elegant, blazingly fast routine that stands as a benchmark against which other code will be judged by. However, this is not the case with TED's fill routine. This slow, stupid algorithm will casually fill one plane of data in a painfully creeping manner. Press ESC when it gets confused." - John Romero on TED (Tile EDitor)

Aliotroph?.postCount++;

[DtM]

1- ZDoom (most flexible, expands Doom abilities)
Equal 2- JDoom (the 3D models and lighting)
Equal 2- Legacy (the 3D blocks and lighting)
3- Edge and Eternity (both outdone by Legacy)
4- Skulltag ('Twill move up the list when finished - looks very promising)

------------------
The best way to remove ACNE, I say, is sandpaper, says I.

[Scorpion]

Style/Layout/Options:
1). Legacy
2). VaVooM
3). PrBooM
4). jDooM
5). ZDooM
6). Skulltag

(Internet) gameplay:
1). ZDooM (ZDaemon)
2). VaVooM
3). Skulltag
4). Legacy
5). jDooM
6). PrBooM

------------------
"I just got a visit from Q. It appears that he wants to do something... nice for me."
-"I'll alert the crew."

[Aliotroph?]

Odd how you rated Vavoom so high on gameplay. Unless it's had a recent update I remember it being slow and now feeling like DooM. Felt like Quake actually. It's very pretty although the particles look horrible.

------------------
"Once in a while a programmer really writes something he's proud of, a slick, elegant, blazingly fast routine that stands as a benchmark against which other code will be judged by. However, this is not the case with TED's fill routine. This slow, stupid algorithm will casually fill one plane of data in a painfully creeping manner. Press ESC when it gets confused." - John Romero on TED (Tile EDitor)

Aliotroph?.postCount++;

[iori]

Legacy
JDoom
Edge
if only legacy had more...
jdoom jumped a place because of DooM64tc!!!

never plyed eternity, but if fragglescript worked PERFECTLY (..didnt legacy get fs from eternity?) i'd like it....wait....didnt they change away from fs?? SHIT!

[picklehammer]

fragglescript is by fraggle and was first used in SMMU

------------------

MSN: pickle_hammer@hotmail.com
ICQ: 74527913
Y!: picklehammer
AIM: picklehammmer27
IRC: ph` (irc.freenode.net #zdoom, #zdaemon, #doom3)

[The Undertaker]

Yes Alio, Vavoom fixed the slow motion bug a few releases back. And for you Zdoom fans, new version's (http://zdoom.notgod.com/lars/2-0-42.cab) out.

[Agent Spork]

I remember trying to play one of my maps in Vavoom... The items would be on top of the 3d floors, instead of on bottom, which would make it impossible to go through the teleporter underneath the floor...

[Thrasher]

I've turned a new leaf, I'm becoming a Zdoomian. I'm leaving the realm of Legacy. Though I might play some Legacy 1.30 here and there, the newer versions have bugs and other problems that are a real turn off, and yet when I report these things, the Legacy guys neither listen or even try to fix them. http://forums.newdoom.com/UBB/frown.gif

1. Zdoom
2. Legacy 1.30

[ToXiCFLUFF]

I can't really say I have a clear-cut preference - It partly depends on the new stuff that is made with them for me. But, considering features too:

1. Legacy: Excellent editing features and stable GL, plus splitscreen (awesome). Just feels right to me, and has done since 2 years ago or something now.

2. Zdoom: I don't like the way it handles (changed physics perhaps?), but good stuff made for it

3. Edge: the best for TC's I would say, because of the excellent DDF

4. Jdoom: nice looking... Don't like the Md2 models. Very poor editing features, so very little groundbreaking addons released for it. Good if you're into looks, or for TC's which stick to GFX mods and Dehacked style editing. I must say though, the particle system is great, I look forward to when it has more features.

Zdoom comes so high because personally, the most impressive maps I have seen in doom have been on this port. "RTC-3057" demo ruled as did "The Gateway Experiments". Shame zdoom no longer runs on my pc - goes to a black screen on startup... god knows why.

Anyway, that's pretty much it. I've got all the major ports, because if an excellent sounding new wad comes out I'm not going to let an insignificant port preference get in the way.

[CheapAlert]

1. Quake
2. Legacy
3. Jdoom
4. Doom95 with screwed up sound pitch.

Those are the only ones I have.

[Agent Spork]

I didn't know Quake was a source port :P

[Doom2Hell]

EDGE

i love the recoil of the weapons http://forums.newdoom.com/UBB/biggrin.gif

------------------
"I never thought i would get so far in life by being so obnoxious"
---Billie Joe Armstrong, Green Day

Visit http://doomwadreview.8m.net for the best wads out there :D

[Doom_Dude]

LOL@Quake

methinks cheap was into the wine again. http://forums.newdoom.com/UBB/tongue.gif

------------------
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad/sig/vilesig1.GIF (http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad/ndcp)
http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad/Ndcp/themegawad.JPG (http://www.newdoom.com/hosted/themegawad)
----Linedef Technician and Sector Maker Upper----

[Mad Max RW]

1. jDoom
2. ZDoom
3. abcdefgDoom